Texas Pacific Land (TPL) Stock Analysis: A Unique Moat in Energy
Texas Pacific Land Corporation (TPL) is one of the most unusual and compelling businesses in our Moatifi screener. While most energy companies drill wells and operate rigs, TPL simply owns land — 880,000 acres of perpetual rights in the heart of the Permian Basin. It collects royalties on production and provides water services, all with zero debt and minimal operational complexity.
Our screener rates TPL at 8/10 overall, ranking it the #2 company in our entire universe.
TPL by the Numbers
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Overall Score | 8/10 |
| Moat Score | 8/10 |
| Management Score | 8/10 |
| Business Quality | 8/10 |
| 5-Year Avg ROE | 45% |
| 5-Year Avg ROIC | 56% |
| Debt/Equity | 0.00 |
| Sector | Energy — Oil & Gas |
That 56% ROIC with zero debt is remarkable. It means every dollar of capital invested in the business generates $0.56 in annual returns — from assets that are literally irreplaceable.
The Moat: Irreplaceable Scarce Assets
TPL's moat is fundamentally different from most companies we analyze. It's not about switching costs, network effects, or brand power. It's about owning something that cannot be replicated.
Perpetual Land and Royalty Rights
TPL traces its roots to 1888, when the Texas and Pacific Railway Company reorganized and its bondholders received 3.5 million acres of West Texas land. Over 130+ years, the company has retained ~880,000 surface acres and extensive royalty interests, most concentrated in the Delaware and Midland basins — the two most productive sub-basins within the Permian.
These rights are perpetual. There is no expiration. No lease renewal risk. No competitor can create more Permian Basin land.
Water Infrastructure
As Permian Basin drilling activity has grown, so has the need for water — both for hydraulic fracturing and for produced water disposal. TPL has built water infrastructure across its vast acreage, creating an additional revenue stream that leverages its irreplaceable land position.
Royalty Income
TPL collects royalties on oil and gas produced on its land — essentially, it gets paid simply for owning the mineral rights below the surface. This is the purest form of a resource moat: income derived from scarcity.
Why the Moat Is Durable
The durability analysis is straightforward:
- Nobody can create more Permian Basin land. This is a finite resource with a 130-year ownership history.
- The Permian Basin is the most productive oil basin in the US. Even in a transition to renewable energy, hydrocarbons will be produced from the Permian for decades.
- Minimal capital requirements. TPL doesn't drill wells or operate rigs. It just owns the land. Capital intensity is extraordinarily low.
- Legal protection. These are legally documented, perpetual rights that have survived over a century of ownership transfers, legal challenges, and economic cycles.
Management Assessment: 8/10
Our analysis notes: "High historical ROE/ROIC, consistent profitability, zero reported financial leverage and positive free cash flow indicate conservative, shareholder-friendly financial stewardship."
Key management qualities: - Zero debt — perhaps the most conservative balance sheet in our entire screener - Disciplined capital allocation — the company has preserved its irreplaceable asset base - Shareholder returns — consistent cash return to shareholders - Simple strategy — management doesn't try to be an oil company; they stick to what they own
Business Quality: 8/10
As our analysis states: "The underlying business is simple and understandable: collect royalties from production on owned land and monetize water services."
The simplicity is the beauty. The unit economics are: - Revenue = f(oil prices × production activity on TPL land) - Costs are minimal (no drilling, no rigs, no massive workforce) - Margins are extraordinary given the asset-light model - Free cash flow conversion is excellent
This is a business Buffett would intuitively understand: own a scarce asset, collect rent, don't mess it up.
Key Risks
Every investment has risks, and TPL has meaningful ones:
1. Commodity Price Exposure
Royalty revenue and water service demand are directly tied to oil & gas prices and drilling activity. A prolonged period of low oil prices would significantly reduce TPL's income. The company can't control commodity prices.
2. Regulatory and Political Risk
Restrictions on fracking, water handling regulations, or changes to mineral/royalty taxation could impact profitability. Environmental regulations around the energy transition are an ongoing concern.
3. Concentration Risk
TPL's value is tied to one geographic basin and specific types of rights. A localized operational disruption, adverse legal ruling, or geological issue could disproportionately affect the company.
Investment Thesis
Our screener's investment thesis captures it well:
"TPL is a Buffett-style candidate because it owns scarce, perpetual land and royalty rights that generate high returns with little leverage — a durable, simple economic franchise with strong balance-sheet conservatism. It remains attractive only with a margin of safety given material exposure to commodity cycles, regulatory risk, and geographic concentration."
The key qualifier: margin of safety matters. TPL's moat is wide, but the business is cyclical. Buying during periods of commodity weakness — when the market prices in worst-case oil scenarios — is the Buffett-style approach.
TPL vs. Other Energy Investments
What makes TPL fundamentally different from typical energy stocks:
| Characteristic | TPL | Typical E&P Company |
|---|---|---|
| Debt | Zero | Often significant |
| Operational complexity | Minimal | High (drilling, operations) |
| Capital requirements | Very low | Very high |
| Asset life | Perpetual | Depleting reserves |
| Margin structure | Very high | Variable |
| Commodity exposure | Yes (royalties) | Yes (production) |
TPL gives you energy exposure with dramatically less operational and financial risk.
View the Complete Analysis
See TPL's full analysis on Moatifi → — including detailed moat reasoning, management assessment, all three risk factors, and the complete investment thesis.
Looking for other unique moat businesses? Explore the Moatifi screener →